33rd Pizza

Enjoy authentic Italian pizza, pastas, and salads at 33rd Pizza in Paterson, NJ. Offering delicious, reasonably priced comfort food with dine-in, delivery, and takeaway options. Visit us for a cozy, historic vibe perfect for lunch, dinner, or groups.

Welcome to 33rd Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

33rd Pizza
33rd Pizza
33rd Pizza
33rd Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Paterson at 519 Park Ave #7, 33rd Pizza stands out as a veteran parlor that champions classic Italian dishes. Since its inception, it has built a reputation for serving authentic pies, antipasto salads, and hearty pastas that evoke the warmth of traditional Italian kitchens. The casual, cozy environment makes it a perfect spot for solo diners, families, or groups craving genuine comfort food. The historic ambiance and friendly staff contribute to an atmosphere that feels like a slice of Italy right in New Jersey. Whether you visit for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, 33rd Pizza promises flavors that connect you to a long-standing tradition of Italian cuisine, delivered with warmth and a touch of local charm.

Enjoy free street parking and easy wheelchair accessibility as you indulge in generously topped pizzas, savory subs, and fresh salads.

Many appreciate its consistent quality, reasonable prices ranging from $10–$20, and welcoming environment that makes every visit feel familiar. A community favorite, it’s a place where history, tradition, and honest food come together in every bite.

Location & Contact

Address

519 Park Ave #7, Paterson, NJ 07504, United States

Phone

+1 973-881-1525

Social Media

About

33rd Pizza
33rd Pizza
33rd Pizza
33rd Pizza

Established as a go-to spot for authentic Italian comfort food, 33rd Pizza has deep roots in the Paterson community, where it operates as a family-run establishment with a history of serving families and individuals since the late 20th century. Owned by seasoned restaurateurs, it embodies a spirit of hospitality and tradition, making it more than just a restaurant—it's a community hub. The menu features a curated selection of Italian classics, including over a dozen pizza varieties, rich pastas, and fresh salads crafted to satisfy every craving. The owners prioritize freshness, quality, and consistency, ensuring every dish meets high standards.

They maintain a warm, welcoming atmosphere, where customers can enjoy hearty portions and prices that respect your budget, from just ten dollars for a slice to twenty for a full meal. The restaurant’s commitment extends to catering to local needs, offering wheelchair access and free street parking. Many loyal patrons recall decades of visits, often celebrating traditions like weekend family dinners or casual solo outings. At 33rd Pizza, authenticity is not just a promise—it's a way of life. The staff is known for going above and beyond, making patrons feel like family.

Whether you’re ordering a ziti to-go or settling in for a relaxed dining experience, 33rd Pizza consistently delivers on its promise of excellent Italian cuisine rooted in community and tradition.

Work Hours

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

33rd Pizza boasts a blend of classic and contemporary Italian favorites, with quick service options like no-contact delivery, takeout, and dine-in. The restaurant’s offerings include more than just pizza; indulge in antipasto salads, hot and cold sandwiches, or comfort dishes like lasagna, chicken parm, and spaghetti—perfect for a quick bite or a hearty meal. The venue caters to diverse needs, from children-friendly menu options to wheelchair accessibility. The busy weekend nights especially highlight its popularity, with Saturday evenings reaching full capacity, but early lunch hours remain less crowded, ideal for a peaceful meal.

Guests consistently praise the restaurant for its cleanliness, friendly service, and authentic flavors that never disappoint. With a neighborhood feel and a focus on tradition, 33rd Pizza keeps the community coming back, one slice at a time. Its commitment to quality, reasonable prices, and a casual vibe make it a dependable choice for Italian food lovers in Paterson.

33rd Pizza

The outside of 33rd Pizza exudes a warm, inviting charm characteristic of classic Italian eateries. The subtle signage and modest storefront guide hungry passersby to a cozy haven filled with the aroma of freshly baked pies. The outdoor area, though modest, offers a friendly street parking ambiance that connects the restaurant to the lively Paterson neighborhood. Step inside, and you'll notice the casual, nostalgic vibe—think vintage photos adorning the walls, cozy booths, and a friendly, welcoming staff.

The atmosphere balances a historic charm with a sense of community tradition. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a sit-down dinner, the ambiance invites relaxation and genuine connection—a perfect backdrop for sharing a pizza or catching up with friends.

Customer Reviews

Very clean 👌 Food Test very good Excellent service above & beyond

L
Luis G.

I've been coming to Frank and Joe's my whole life; my family had a tradition of buying a pie every Saturday and eating together. My parents came to the United States in 1986 and lived across the street from the pizzeria. We loved the staff and coming every week to get delicious pizza. I was very sad to see that this location is now 33rd pizza but I am so thankful to you all for providing such a wonderful experience for so long. You will always have a place in our hearts.

V
Victoria A.

I've been going to this place since I was 13 years old. The pizza the dinners and the deli sandwiches have not changed one bit. The prices are reasonable even to this day and the servings are of proper size or better. This time I got in Italian hero and it was amazing and so fresh tasting. I can honestly say you cannot go wrong here. Thanks guys for years of consistent service and great flavor.

D
Dee N.

This was my first visit and I'll definitely return. If you grew up in New Jersey in the 70s or 80s, you'll definitely recognize this sort of pizza place. It's a no-frills environment, but a real quality slice. And the prices are very reasonable. Owner us charming and you'll be treated with respect. Next time I'm getting a meatball hero!

J
Jack S.

Food is good. Yes 💯

S
Shadeen R.

Simply the best pizza I’ve never had in my life. The place looks like where good fellas or any other good Italian movie filming took place not much as changed but pizza is one of the best. God bless you guys for changing my pizza experience and taste.

H
Hamdaiil